Thursday, May 3, 2012

Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick


    From her work, I learnt a new word Homosocial, a word difference from homosexual; oppositely, it describes social bonds between persons of the same sex. Sedgwick argues that "sexuality" and  "desire" were not a historial phenomenon but carefully managed social constracts. She also uses Foucault's theories of the history of sexuality to reproduce Feminism and Gay and Lesbian Studies.
       It also arises my curiosity of the difference between female and male.

Henry Louis Gates Jr.


Talking Black: Critical signs of the Tiems

    For long time, I have been wondering about race problem in America. I feel the whites really misunderstand others especially on the African American culture. Gates give people a frank analysis in his work to argue with those bias from tradition. Besides, the black text or the black tradition is valued to the literary field. 

Martha C. Nussbaum


    After studying her work, I cannot help to think of an old saying by an ancient Chinese author---- Women are made of water. It may too rough by my translation, but I really want to express my feeling for her " Cultivating Humanity"---- as soft as water spreading into my mind.
About her interpretation on plot of Sophocles, the cultivation acts as nymph to connect the drama and the audience. This way, a work profoundly awakes the sleeping soul.
Here the arts play a vital role, cultivating powers of imagination that are essential to citizenship.
    This theory can be seen in many literary works. In Emily Bronte's Wuthering Height, the figure Heathcliff at the dying bed finding his original humanity hiding in the deepest part of his heart. Though he did his revenge to both families crudely, his unfair life experience draws the sympathy of the audience to his inside feeling. His rage and revenge are seen as the reimburse from an unjustified life. However, a wild life was eventually cultivated on his deathbed to back to his original soul so that the novel at the end brings a light of hope to people. The work practice the cultivating power to the audience which agrees with Nussbaum's theory of Cultivating Humanity.

Stephen J. Greenblatt

                                                             
Review from Resonance and Wonder 

     "The aesthetic wonder that texts arouse as well as their historical resonance". Greenblatt named the New Historicism which is an interest in the embeddedness of cultural objects in the contingencies of history. It is a distictive literary criticism from the traditional historicism, which opposite to the formalism and structuralism. The theory is a culturally poetic study on explaining the literature relates to history and politics. Another word, he emphasizes on the interaction of reality and history and politics, rather than thinking the history as just an event under a certain time.
    New historicism is different from the others like marxism as a doctrine, instead, it is more like a practice. First, the literature is a historic reflection which needs to be studied and researched on its historic characters and events. Secondly, it is also important to study the author because the author would be varied on characteristics, different times and environments. Thirdly, it is no necessary restoring in the traditional historicism---- to discover the affection of history on the context, while the context reflects the history.
    To conclude, according to his theory, the literature reflects the past and the present while the reality is led or affected by the literature---- "the touch of the real"---- re-creating the social and cultural negotiations of a historical moment.

Edward W Said

The Orient is not only adjacent to Europe; it is also the place of Europe's greatest and richest and oldest colonies, the source of its civilizations and languages, its cultural contestant, and one of its deepest and most recurring images of the Oter. In addition the orient has helped to define Europe (or the West) as its contrasting image, idea, personality, experience.

    Orientalism is a structure created by western power, colonism. It has two meanings: From the linguistic study, culture and anthropology, orient and occient are distinct. From the politics, the overstatement of West about their own opinion or idea of Orient "represents part culturally and even ideologically", but not the actual one. In his work, middle-east exemplifies orientalism----for western people, it expresses either the oil provider or the potential terrorism. Thus, the orientalism is an incomplete perspective by the west which is controlled by the idea of procolonism.

    Besides, Said has the flaw on his theory---- he only focus on the middle-esat as the Orient. However, the middle-east can only represent part of orient. Therefore, in my opinion, he overlook the other part of asia to work on his theory.

Stanley Fish

A New Idea About Reading

    "There is no right way (formula) to read the text. " I would like Fish's idea because it makes sense for me to think actively while I am reading, rather than just collecting the stuffs from a text. For me, I think an active reading make the interaction between the author and the readers, this way could be as giving a life to a literary work. At same time, Fish's theories prove the necessity of literary criticism, which an extraordinary process on modern criticism.
    Stanley Fish gives the readers the infinite space to absorb the information from the literary works. He breaks the limitation from the convention view of the relationship between the audience and the book. If his view of "The text doesn't exist, it's only from the reader, and the reader makes the text" is true, it will undoubtedly give a push to the readers to read, to think, and create positively.
    His theory also emphasizes on the importance of reading. Reading is a process requires optional ideas. Without reading, a book would lose the meaning of its existence. While the author takes the role who introduce a group of informations to the reader, the reader would work on collecting those informations and create one's own thought about it. Yet the produce from reading a text varies among the people. Therefore, there is no a certain way to read, and the text is made by the readers.

Wednesday, May 2, 2012

Lennard Davis

http://www.lennarddavis.com/home.html
The Existence of Varied Bodies In a Same Big World
Review from Disability Studies
    
    The patient with mental problem is always relate to "insane" and "uncontrollable" or something with crime. Those irrational images with the bias or discriminations limit the space of living for the disable people. The most of them are excluded joining the society cause of the potentially inexplicable dread or obstruction, thus "Once a man is prescribed as psychiatrically “abnormal”, he is sentenced to death because they are being isolated, incarcerated and even eliminated. "
    The world we are living in contains varied kind of lives, and everybody is different. The one's own particular signs diversity the world. However, there is a standard ("disability comes into consciousness after the construction of the concept “normalcy”) to distinguish "abnormal" and "normal", which implies those "abnormal" are disable and deficient. According to Lennard Davis, "normal" and "average" appeared until 19th Centruy. Thus, there should not have had those "natural standard" in the world. While the standard was built, those outside the "standard" would be "abnormal, unit, defective".
Undoubtedly some people with any different features or appearances would be the objects for others whom to be judged as unusual strangers.
    Davis states how brutal the situation is for the disable people. It is like fascist to saluter by distinct the people with the theory of good human race. Because we are judging people with the "standard" which makes the "abnormal" people have to be hide, otherwise, the living space is too tight to stay.  A normal soul would be crushed by this way not cause of the furious, but the crude reality. 
    What if the world can think about this problem with a multiple point of view? "Then there is no 'hegemony of normalcy' which has violently makes people unfit to the norm excluded from society. The world is big, big enough to hold all the differences; the world is big, big enough to be enjoyed by everyone.  

Frantz Fanon & Colonism

"Frantz Fanon's relatively short life yielded two potent and influential statements of anti-colonial revolutionary thought, Black Skin, White Mask(1952) and The Wretched of the Earth (1961), works which have made Fanon a prominent contributor to postcolonial studies." (http://english.emory.edu/Bahri/Fanon.html)

To overcome the binary system in which black is bad and white is good, Fanon argues that an entirely new world must come into being. This utopian desire, to be absolutely free of the past, requires total revolution, "absolute violence" (37). Violence purifies, destroying not only the category of white, but that of black too. According to Fanon, true revolution in Africa can only come from the peasants, or "fellaheen." Putting peasants at the vanguard of the revolution reveals the influence of the FLN, who based their operations in the countryside, on Fanon's thinking. Furthermore, this emphasis on the rural underclass highlights Fanon's disgust with the greed and politicking of the comprador bourgeoisie in new African nations. The brand of nationalism espoused by these classes, and even by the urban proletariat, is insufficient for total revolution because such classes benefit from the economic structures of imperialism. Fanon claims that non-agrarian revolutions end when urban classes consolidate their own power, without remaking the entire system. In his faith in the African peasantry as well as his emphasis on language, Fanon anticipates the work of Ngugi Wa Thiong'o, who finds revolutionary artistic power among the peasants.
German Colonism in Qingdao, Shandong Province in China in World War I


    It was hard to imagine the city Qingdao has been a colony of German and Japanese hundreds during World War I. I have never been to that city, but other cities in Shandong Province. It really impressed me of the people in Shandong are very friendly traditional Chinese. They inherit very traditional culture of Confucius. However, learning about the colonic history of this city just blow out all my old opinions about it.
Modern Qindao
    Qingdao is a bay city in Shandong Province which map in middle-east part of China. The modern urbanization can be tell clearly. Hundreds years, it was a small city likes a village on the bay area of East China Sea. It may offer the easier way for Germany to land and to built the colony. At present, there is a German town was kept in the city for people the remember the history. Besides, Germany built the city of Qingdao, which makes it being on industrialization earlier than other cities in China. And it brings the opportunity to Qingdao to become a industrial modern city in China. Moreover, it is very interesting about the Beer Festival in Qingdao. I did not ever think about it would be relate to the German culture of beer. Thus, that is evidence to display that Qingdao was impacts profoundly by German colonism.
     
      An university building in Qindao with German style


Learn more from here: http://www.echinacities.com/qingdao/city-life/exploring-old-qingdao-a-guide-to-the-area-s-main_1.html

Nothrop Frye

Born in 1912 in Canada, died in 1991.
Educated at University of Toronto, Emmanuel College, and Merton College in Oxford.
His wrote 40, among which Anatomy of Criticism is one of his most important contributions.
Frye views literature as an ongoing conversation; writers respond to each other. Richter explains that for Frye: "Each generation rewrites the stories of the past in ways that make sense for it, recycling a vast tradition over the ages" (641). 
(http://faculty.csusb.edu/ramirez/fall03/frye.html)


The archetype of literature

Section I.
action    art                wisdom
history    humanities    philosophy
events    criticism        ideas
art---->criticism; this should be a science
nature---->physics, etc.; this is a science
Criticism should have the appearance of a science; right now there is too much junk in literary analysis--to much opinion based on issues of taste rather than some organizing principle of evaluation.
We need principles to distinguish the significant from the meaningless; we need to keep the text/literature in the center.
We can't rely on value judgments that are casual--this is chitchat and pseudo criticism.  We need a systematic approach and we need to consider the reader in a rhetorical sense, but we also have to undertake a structural analysis that assumes an overarching coherence.
Literary criticism can rely on patterns
Section II
A critic's role is to look for connection between the poet and the poem, but there are also unconscious influences and their are myths and symbols that have been inherited.
Two ways to proceed: inductive and deductive
Inductive--look for patterns, make educated guesses
Deductve--look for consequences, look for coherence and try to categorize
There are two ways of thinking about genre:
1) that there is a platonic, pre-existing form
Note: there are archetypes of genres as well as of images
2) that the social conditions produced the work (Gothic, Baroque, etc.).
Literary criticism is the history of ideas; it moves from the analysis of the primitive to the analysis of the sophisticated
Perspective is gained by approaching the text closely and then backing up for perspective; this is induction.
Section III.
This section deals with deductive reasoning, the principle of recurrence
Examination of time and space, narrative and meaning
rhythm=narrative
pattern=meaning
Myths:
dawn, spring
zenith, summer
sunset, autumn,
darkness, winter
Structural approach based on archetypes: flood, sea, etc.
Epiphanies give meaning to these archetypes and wed the dream world and the hero
Visions: comictragic 

Simone De Beauvoir


                               "Each of us is responsible for everything and to every human being."
1908-1986
Birth place
Paris, France
Works
                                         The Second Sex; Ethics of Ambiguity; The Mandarins;etc
Reveiw
The Second Sex speaks of the specific ways in which the natural and social sciences and the European literary, social, political and religious traditions have created a mystified world where impossible and conflicting ideals of femininity produce an ideology of women's “natural” inferiority to justify patriarchal domination. The book is based on her experience as a woman and her life in reality as a woman.
 “One is not born but becomes a woman” (The Second Sex, 267)
It introduces the meaning of the sex-gender distinction. 
"Beauvoir's The Second Sex gave us the vocabulary for analyzing the social constructions of femininity and the structure for critiquing these constructions. From a phenomenological perspective this most famous line of The Second Sex pursues the first rule of phenomenology: suspend judgments, identify your assumptions, treat them as prejudices and put them aside; do not bring them back into play until and unless they have been validated by experience." 

William K. Wimsatt JR. & Monroe C. Beardsley


What is Fallacy?
The intentional fallacy----what the reader responses to create or expand a new idea from the work, which is as same as the intention of the author.
The affective fallacy---- what the poem relates to the reality, and affects on people.
The philosophy of intentional fallacy suggests that, in literary criticism, the original meaning of the author is, perhaps, not the most important or correct interpretation of the work. In other words, there should be more freedom for the readers to interpret what they want from the information they receive. The concept is credited with first being introduced by William K.Wimsatt Jr., and Monroe Beardsley in 1946, and represents one opinion on literary criticism.
Intentional fallacy allows the readers a great deal of subjective freedom in determining what the work may say. Like anything, those readers who can make the strongest arguments to back up their points will likely receive more favorable responses. While it may seem as though this would change the meaning from what the author intended, it may or may not. If the author is clear in what is being written, readers may come to the same conclusion as the author.
Some may also apply this philosophy to other works of art, not just literature. For some works of art, interpretation is a key factor to an individual's enjoyment of that piece. Depending on how esoteric, or vague, a certain piece of art may be, it could be subject to a wide array of interpretations, especially if being viewed in a different time period than that in which it was created. Therefore, paintings, drawings, and sculptures could mean profoundly different things to different people.


Cleanth Brooks


The New Criticism that Brooks championed seems to have been a means of coming to terms with the literary modernism that emerged in the early twentieth century in the writings of Eliot, Yeats, Pound, and Joyce, and in their successors. The criticism of T. S. Eliot, in particular, sought a critical and historical justification for his own difficult and obscure poetry in the French symbolists and the English metaphysical poets of the seventeenth century, and Eliot's revaluation of these poets implied a revision of literary history-or of the literary canon, to put it in contemporary terms.

Brooks' achievement was to apply the method of close reading, with its emphasis on poetic tension, or paradox, or irony, to virtually the entire English and American literary tradition, including prose fiction and drama as well as nondramatic verse. His early critical works like Modern Poetry and the Tradition (1939) and, especially, The Well Wrought Urn (1947) were very influential in this development; but undoubtedly his most enduring contribution to literary education arises from the anthologies he edited for college students in freshman composition and introductory literature courses: Understanding Poetry (1938), Understanding Fiction(1943) with Robert Penn Warren, and Understanding Drama (1945) with Robert B. Heilman.

Mikhail M. Badhtin

(1895–1975), Russian cultural and literary theorist whose life and works remain the object of controversies. Several key episodes in his life are shrouded in mystery, and the textual history of his works is extremely complicated due in part to the political context in which they were written.
Read more: http://www.answers.com/topic/mikhail-m-bakhtin#ixzz1tjWN0juN
Dialogical:
1) self----the soul of the idea----reflects the potentially capability, value.
2) self and others---- different language, no voice can be isolated.
In order to understand, it is immensely important for the person who understands to be located outside the object of his or her creative understanding—in time, in space, in culture. For one cannot even really see one's own exterior and comprehend it as a whole, and no mirrors or photographs can help; our real exterior can be seen and understood only by other people, because they are located outside us in space, and because they are others. ~New York Review of Books, June 10, 1993.
Anyone will have a other who think about him or her. The dialogue between people is not only oneself's thoughts in some culture and situation, but also the idea of the language reflects the point of view from others---- how others to see this oneself.
3)vocies: "averaged", "synthesized"---->truth. 

Erich Auerbach

http://www.phillwebb.net/topics/arts/literature/History/Auerbach/Auerbach.htm
"He who represents the course of a human life, or a sequence of events extending over a prolonged period of time, and represents it from beginning to end, must prune and isolate arbitrary. Life has always long since begun, and it is always still going on. And the people whose story the author is telling experience much more than he can ever hope to tell. But the things that happen to a few individuals in the course of a few minutes, hours, possibly even days - these one can hope to report with reasonable completeness." (Auerbach in Mimesis)
 "The work is a strikingly successful combination of philology, stylistics, history of ideas and sociology, of meticulous learning and artistic taste, of historical imagination and awareness of our own age." (from A History of Modern Criticism 1970-1950, Volume 7, 1991)

Review:
The literature work is not simply record a historical event or the surface things, but it should be include some deeply significant meanings which underneath the context. Besides, the depiction of every day life reflects the reality. The connection of literature and society and history is a new concept of realism which emphasizes on the relationship between literary works and the reality. His view of mimesis refers the inner consciousness.

Wednesday, March 7, 2012

T.S.Eliot & John Crowe Ransom


"In English writing we seldom speak of tradition", "The past isn't dead, not even past".
      For Eliot, tradition is the basic element of the poem; and an excellent poet is the capable of broadening the tradition within the pome. His poem presents the recur of the times to express the poet is thinking about the past in the present.
Burnt Norton
(No. 1 of 'Four Quartets')
Time present and time past

Are both perhaps present in time future,

I
                                            Time present and time past 
                                            Are both perhaps present in time future,
                                            And time future contained in time past.
                                            If all time is eternally present
                                            All time is unredeemable.
                                            What might have been is an abstraction
                                            Remaining a perpetual possibility
                                           Only in a world of speculation.
                                           What might have been and what has been
                                           Point to one end, which is always present.
                                           Footfalls echo in the memory
                                           Down the passage which we did not take
                                           Towards the door we never opened
                                           Into the rose-garden. My words echo
                                           Thus, in your mind.
                                           But to what purpose
                                           Disturbing the dust on a bowl of rose-leaves
                                           I do not know.
                              
                               (http://evans-experientialism.freewebspace.com/eliot_burnt_norton.htm)

Thursday, March 1, 2012

Virginia Woolf & Doris Lessing

Adeline Virginia Woolf (25 January 1882 – 28 March 1941) was an English author, essayist, publisher, and writer of short stories, regarded as one of the foremost modernist literary figures of the twentieth century. 
A Room of One's Own
The essay is generally seen as a feminist text, and is noted in its argument for both a literal and figural space for women writers within a literary tradition dominated by patriarchy.
"a woman must have money and a room of her own if she is to write fiction"
"In the first place, to have a room of her own..was out of the question, unless her parents were exceptionally rich or very noble"
                           
               The echo from Woolf's A Room of One's Own
                                                                                          -----Room Nineteen by Doris Lessing 

It is a story about a middle aged woman who has been from happiness to madness in her marriage, eventually gone to devastate. In 1960's, the society still restrains women to limit their living space. The main character Susan was happy with her husband and 4 kids in their family. However, they both start to doubt the real meaning of life. Since the husband has a affair, Susan changes from "it still under the control" to be irritable of her life. She starts to feel the emptiness and laking of freedom in her marriage. She wearies of the role of sustainer and comforter. The question of her decision of marriage is intelligent and fulfillment strikes her inner feeling. She finds out her identity through the self-discovery. Finally, she refuses to regress to the old self and to abdicate self-knowledge and self role, thus she remains the true to the authentic self. However, she choose to kill herself, which claims a means of resisting of crushing, culturally enforced image of woman and of posting a new politics of identity. The story denounces the devastating consequences of the restrictions to women in that era. 

W.E.B. Dubois & Zora Neale Hurston


(1868- 1963) William Edward Burghardt Du Bois was a noted scholar, editor, and African American activist. Du Bois was a founding member of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP -- the largest and oldest civil rights organization in America). Throughout his life Du Bois fought discrimination and racism. He made significant contributions to debates about race, politics, and history in the United States in the first half of the 20th century, primarily through his writing and impassioned speaking on race relations. 
Criteria of Negro Art
Such is Beauty. Its variety is infinite, its possibility is endless. In normal life all may have it and have it yet again. The world is full of it; and yet today the mass of human beings are choked away from it, and their lives distorted and made ugly. This is not only wrong, it is silly. 
...especially those who are weary of the eternal struggle along the color line, who are afraid to fight and to whom the money of philanthropists and the alluring publicity are subtle and deadly bribes.
Zora Neale Hurston was one of the most prolific African-American female writers of her day. Between 1934 and 1948, Hurston published seven books including her autobiographyDust Tracks on a Road.  Perhaps her most well received publication was Their Eyes Were Watching God.  Inaddition to her major publications, she also wrote many short stories, plays, biographies, newspaper and magazine articles.
     Hurston was born in the all-black town of Eatonville, Florida.  Eatonville was the setting for many of her stories of folklore and probably shaped many of her political views.


Characteristics of Negro Expression

  • The Negro's universal mimicry is not so much a thing in itself as an evidence of something that permeates his entire sel. And that thing is drama. 
  • The will to adorn is the second most notable characteristic in Negro expresssion. Perhaps his idea of ornament does not attempt to meet conventional standards, but it satisfies the soul of its creator. 
  • Asymmetry is a definite feature of Negro art... but the sculpture and carvings are full of this beauty and lack of symmetry. 
  • Imitation----The Negro, the world over, is famous as a mimic.  
  • Mimicry is an art in itself.
http://www.howard.edu/library/reference/guides/hurston/

Ferdinand de Saussure

 The sign, the signifier, and the signified are concepts of the school of thought known as structuralism, founded  
by Ferdinand de Saussure, a Swiss linguist, during lectures he gave between 1907 and 1911 at the University of Geneva. His views revolutionized the study of language and inaugurated modern linguistics. The theory also profoundly influenced other disciplines, especially anthropology, sociology, and literary criticism. The central tenet of structuralism is that the phenomena of human life, whether language or media, are not intelligible except through their network of relationships, making the sign and the system (or structure) in which the sign is embedded primary concepts. As such, a sign -- for instance, a word -- gets its meaning only in relation to or in contrast with other signs in a system of signs.
In general, the signifier and the signified are the components of the sign, itself formed by the associative link between the signifier and signified. Even with these two components, however, signs can exist only in opposition to other signs. That is, signs are created by their value relationships with other signs. The contrasts that form between signs of the same nature in a network of relationships is how signs derive their meaning.
In Saussure's theory of linguistics, the signifier is the sound and the signified is the thought. The linguistic sign is neither conceptual nor phonic, neither thought nor sound. Rather, it is the whole of the link that unites sound and idea, signifier and signified. The properties of the sign are by nature abstract, not concrete. Saussure: "A sign is not a link between a thing and a name, but between a concept and a sound pattern"

  • The linguistic sign unites, not a thing and a name, but a concept and a sound-image.
  • The linguistic sign is arbitrary;
  • The word symbol has been used to designate the linguistic sign, or more specifically, what is here called the signifier.
  • The word arbitrary also calls for comment.
  • The signifier, being auditory, is unfolded solely in time from which it gets the following characteristics: (a) it represents a span, and (b) the span is measurable in a single dimension; it is a line.
  • Diachronic- a word over time
  • Synchronic-any given moment
  • Signifier(sound image) + Signified(concept) = Sign

 http://www.criticism.com/md/the_sign.html

Sigmund Freud

Along with Charles Darwin, Karl Marx, and Albert Einstein, he helped revolutionize the modern Western conception of human life and its place in the universe. For Freud, human reason was not master in its own house but a precarious defense mechanism struggling against, and often motivated by, unconscious desires and forces. His theory and practice of psychoanalysis have changed the way people think about themselves today, whether they are aware of it or not. At same time, psychoanalysis has been controversial from the beginning because, unlike experimental science it cannot be adequately tested, falsified, or objectified.
The "Uncanny"
The "Uncanny"---- is undoubtedlly related to what is frightening----to what arouses dread and horror; equally certainly, too, the word is not always used in a clearly definable sense, so that it tends to coincide with what excites fear in general.
'uncanny'='unfamiliar'
The term 'repression' beyond its legitimate meaning. It would be more correct to take into account a psychological distinction which can be detected here, and to say that the animistic beliefs of civilized people are in a state of having been (to a greater or lesser extent) surmounted [rather than repressed]. Our conclusion could then be stated thus: an uncanny experience occurs either when infantile complexes which have been repressed are once more revived by some impression, or when primitive beliefs which have been surmounted seem once more to be confirmed. 
Fetishism
Fetish is recognized by its adherents as an abnormality, it is seldom felt by them as the symptom of an ailment accompanied by suffering.

  • Super ego
  • Ego/conscious
  • ID/ unconcious
  • The core of dream: wish



Friedrich Nietzsche

Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900) is the wild man, the self-proclaimed anti-Christ, of Western thought. A brilliant polemicist, he champions energy over reason and art over science while contmptuous of the quiet, "timid" virtues of domesticity, democracy, and peace. He is absolutely central to modern and postmodern attempts to rethink the Western tradtion's most fundamental assumptions.
He was born in Röcken, a small village in Prussian Saxony. He was the son and grandson of Lutheran ministers. Having received his doctorate at the University of Leipzig, Nietzsche was appointed professor of philology at the Univeristy of Basel in Switzerland in 1869. He met Wagner and Cosima von Bülow in late 1868, and his first book, The Birth of Tragedy(1872), combines a new theory of Greek tragedy with an extended argument that Wagner's work constitutes a German rebirth of that ancient form.
On Truth and Lying in a Non-Moral Sense
What do human beings really know about themselves? Are they even capable of perceiving themselves in their entirety just once, stretched out as in an illuminated glass case? Does nature not reman silent about almost everything, even about our bodies, banishing and enclosing us within a proud, illusory consciousness, far away from the twists and turns of the bowels, the rapid flow of the blood stream and the complicated trembling of the nerve-fibres? Nature has thrown away the key...

  • Truth is a comfortable lie; it suggest that "the world [is] something which is similar in kind to humanity," and it boosts self-confidence, the untroubled conviction of being right. While Nietzsche is scornful of this smug"Anthropomorphism," he does underline its utility.
  • This "first metaphor" introduces an unbridgeable gap, which leas Nietzsche to conclude that " subject and object" are "absolutely different spheres."
  • Once Nietzsche pulls the veil of illusion from our eyes and shows that truth is a "mobile army of metaphors, metonymies, anthropomorphisms,"
The Birth of Tragedy
In the views described here we already have all the constituent elements of a profound and pessimistic way of looking at the world and thus, at the same time, of the doctrine of the Mysteries taught by tragedy: the fundamental recognition that everything which exists is a unity; the view that individuation is the primal source of all evil; and art as the joyous hope that the spell of individuation can be broken a premonition of unity restored.

Matthew Arnold

Although remembered now for his elegantly argued critical essays, Matthew Arnold (1822-1888) began his career as a poet, winning early recognition as a student at the Rugby School where his father, Thomas Arnold, had earned national acclaim as a strict and innovative headmaster. Arnold also studied at Balliol College, Oxford University. In 1844, after completing his undergraduate degree at Oxford, he returned to Rugby as a teacher of classics.

  • Belief: The literature shapes culture.

Culture and anarchy
He defended culture against scientific materialism. culture means qualities of independent thinking and intellectual open-mindness.
  1. He advocated that culture perfection can prevent corruption and help to curb the worship of material wealth. "The pursuit of perfection is the pursuit of sweetness and light."
  2. "Sweetness and light"---- suggests reasonableness of temper and intellectual insight.
  3. The society should be "permeated by thought, sensible to beauty, intelligent and alive."
  4. His concept of culture includes the political, the social and the religious aspects of life.
  5. Culture should be the most effective way to cure the ills of a sick society.
  6. The middle class in England is narrow minded and corrupted by materialism, therefore the world sold be dominated by a group of people who not qualified to play a leading role in the development of society. He tried to wake up those people, and to make them ware of the importance of improving themselves culturally.

Essay in Criticism(1865, 1888)
  1. He expressed his understanding of social function of an artist in the Victorian age.
  2. Literary criticism means a great deal more than simple book-reviewing.
  3. Good criticism is " a disinterested endeavor to learn and propagate the best that is known and thought in the world, and thus to establish a current of fresh and true ideas."
  4. Critics helps people to "see the object as in it really is".
  5. Critism extends beyound literature; criticism has social function to foster the sublime spirit of age.
  6. The poem should be serious and truthfu.

Dover Beach
  1. Religious forward: Tendency to relay 
  2. Religion fulfills literature to make the society processing in order properly.
  3. Religion as socially cohesive element literature (poetry) as religion's surrogate social conservative.

The Function of Criticism at the Present Time
  1. It is noticeable that the word curiosity, which in other languages is used in a good sense, to mean, as a high and fine quality of amn's nature, just this disinterested love of a fee play of the mind on all subjects for its own sake, ----it is noticeable, I say, that this word has in our language no sense of the kind, no sense but a rather bad and disparaging one. 
  2. Real criticism, is essentically the exercise of this very quality. It obeys and instinct prompting it to try to know the best that is known and thought in the world, irrespectively of practice, politic, and everything of the kind...

Karl Marx and Raymond Williams


Karl Marx
The worker becomes all the poorer the more wealth he produces, the more his production increases in power and range. The worker becomes an ever cheaper commodity the more commodities he creates. With the increasing value of the world of things proceeds in direct proportion to the devaluationof the world of men. Labour produces not only commodities; it produces itself and the worker as a commodity -- and does so in the proportion in which it produces commodities generally.    
                                  Marx, Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts (1844)
Engels
Marx was expelled from Paris at the end of 1844 and with Engels, moved to Brussels where he remained for the next three years, visiting England where Engels' family had cotton spinning interests in Manchester. While in Brussels Marx devoted himself to an intensive study of history and elaborated what came to be known as the materialist conception of history. This he developed in a manuscript (published posthumously as The German Ideology), of which the basic thesis was that "the nature of individuals depends on the material conditions determining their production." Marx traced the history of the various modes of production and predicted the collapse of the present one -- industrial capitalism -- and its replacement by communism.
At the same time Marx was composing The German Ideology, he also wrote a polemic (The Poverty of Philosophy) against the idealistic socialism of P. J. Proudhon (1809-1865). He also joined the Communist League. This was an organization of German émigr?workers with its center in London of which Marx and Engels became the major theoreticians. At a conference of the League in London at the end of 1847 Marx and Engels were commissioned to write a succinct declaration of their position. Scarcely was The Communist Manifesto published than the 1848 wave of revolutions broke out in Europe.
"Morality, religion, metaphysics, all the rest of ideology and their corresponding forms of consciousness, thus no longer retain the semblance of independence. They have no his tory, no development; but men, developing their material production and their material intercourse, alter, along with this their real existence, their thinking and the products of their thinking." (Karl Marx, The German Ideology)
Raymond Williams
Raymond Williams  (31 August 1921 – 26 January 1988) was born in Llanfihangel Crucorney, near Abergavenny, Wales, Williams was the son of a railway worker in a village where all of the railwaymen voted Labour while the local small farmers mostly voted Liberal. 

He was a Welsh academic, novelist and critic. He was an influential figure within the New Left and in wider culture. His writings on politics, culture, the mass media and literature are a significant contribution to the Marxist critique of culture and the arts. Some 750,000 copies of his books have sold in UK editions alone and there are many translations available. His work laid the foundations for the field of cultural studies and the cultural materialist approach.
'The base' is the real social existence of man. 'The base' is the real relations of production sorresponding to a stage of development of the material productive forces. 'The base' is a mode of production at a particular stage of its development."
"productive forces" is to give just brief reminders, the most important thing a worker ever produces is himself, himself in the fact of  that kind of labour, of the broader historical emphasis of men producing themselves, themselves and their history. 
Hegemony: governing class, ruling class.